Skip to content

Shanice

Shanice represented the cruelty that can flourish when no one challenges it. A senior volunteer at the West Baltimore Recreation Center for three years, she established a toxic hierarchy that other volunteers arranged themselves around to avoid becoming targets. Her casual dismissal of disabled children, her social dominance through intimidation, and her willingness to use her position to exclude and demean those she deemed inconvenient went unchecked for years—until the Summer 2014 arrival of Kelsey Morrison and Shanice's own escalation from neglect to assault. When Shanice grabbed twelve-year-old MJ and shook him hard enough to leave bruises, then used a slur against him in text messages, she crossed a line that couldn't be walked back. Her suspension and the subsequent reckoning forced everyone who'd enabled her to confront their own complicity.

Position at the Recreation Center

Shanice had been volunteering at the West Baltimore Recreation Center for three years by Summer 2014—longer than any other current volunteer. This seniority, combined with her forceful personality, allowed her to establish and maintain the social hierarchy among volunteers. She set the tone. She decided who was in and who was out. She drove away volunteers who didn't fall in line.

Her approach to the children reflected this same pattern: those who were easy to work with received attention; those who required more effort—like MJ with his disabilities and fatigue—were dismissed as inconveniences to be managed rather than children to be served.

Personality

Shanice wielded social power through force of personality. She established dominance through attitude and expected everyone to fall in line. When challenged, she responded with escalating coldness and dismissal. When Kelsey questioned MJ's treatment on day one, Shanice's voice shifted from "friendly to patronizing" and then to ice.

She had a talent for making cruelty sound reasonable. "He's disabled. He gets tired. We leave him alone." "We work with the resources we have. We can't give special treatment to one kid just because he's got issues." Each justification reframed neglect as practicality, exclusion as accommodation.

To those she dated, like Devon, she could be possessive and subtly demeaning—making comments about his lack of ambition, his laziness, his failure to live up to his potential. She tore him down while keeping him close, creating a dynamic where his compliance felt like the path of least resistance.

Cultural Identity and Heritage

Shanice was a Black woman from Baltimore whose cultural identity made her cruelty toward MJ particularly pointed. As a Black woman in America, she had experienced the dehumanization of racism—had been reduced to stereotypes, had been dismissed and diminished by systems that didn't see her as fully human. She knew what slurs did. She knew how language could strip a person of dignity. And she turned that knowledge against someone more vulnerable than herself, using the r-slur against a disabled Black child as casually as if his humanity were a matter of opinion.

This dynamic—harm flowing within rather than only across identity categories—reflected a reality that communities often struggle to acknowledge: that shared racial identity does not prevent intra-community cruelty, that Black children with disabilities can be failed by the very communities that should hold them, that the same systems of dominance and dehumanization that operate between racial groups also reproduce themselves within them. Shanice's three-year reign at the rec center was built on the same logic that sustains any hierarchy of power: she decided who mattered and who didn't, who deserved engagement and who could be dismissed as inconvenient, who was fully human and who was "some retarded kid who doesn't even know what's happening half the time." That a Black woman in Baltimore could replicate the very dynamics of exclusion and dehumanization that racism itself produces was not a contradiction—it was a reminder that oppression teaches its victims its methods as surely as it teaches them its pain.

Speech and Communication Patterns

Shanice had a talent for making cruelty sound reasonable. She could shift from friendly to patronizing to ice in moments, wielding tone as a weapon of social control. Her language consistently reframed neglect as practicality and exclusion as accommodation: "He's disabled. He gets tired. We leave him alone." "We work with the resources we have. We can't give special treatment to one kid just because he's got issues." Each justification stripped away the humanity of the child she was describing while maintaining the surface appearance of reasonableness.

In text messages after the assault, her communication shifted to manipulation and self-victimization: demanding Devon's loyalty, minimizing the harm she'd caused, escalating to slurs when challenged.

Health and Disabilities

[No health conditions were documented for Shanice.]

Personal Style and Presentation

[Shanice's physical appearance and personal style were not documented.]

Tastes and Preferences

[To be established.]

Habits, Routines, and Daily Life

[To be established.]

Personal Philosophy or Beliefs

[Shanice's philosophy, insofar as it could be inferred from her actions, centered on a hierarchy of human value determined by convenience and social utility. Those who were easy to work with received her attention; those who required more effort were dismissed as inconveniences. She wielded social power through force of personality and expected compliance, responding to challenge with escalating coldness. Whether this worldview was shaped by her own experiences of dehumanization—she knew what slurs did, had experienced the dehumanization of racism—and then replicated against someone more vulnerable, or whether it reflected something more deeply rooted, remained unexamined.]

Treatment of MJ

Shanice's treatment of MJ exemplified her approach to anyone she deemed inconvenient. For months—possibly years—she'd been dismissing him as "the kid who sleeps," talking about him like he wasn't there, excluding him from activities without attempting alternatives.

Her language revealed her true views: she described him as someone who "can't really do much," who had "some kind of syndrome or whatever," who was "always sleeping anyway." She talked about him within his hearing, treating him as furniture rather than a person who could understand what was being said about him.

When his friends—Tre, Darnell, Kevin, and Jamal—tried to advocate for him, Shanice shut them down. When Kelsey challenged the system, Shanice dismissed her as "the new girl" who didn't understand "how things work here."

The Assault

On a Friday in Summer 2014, Shanice's treatment of MJ escalated from neglect to physical assault.

After Kelsey and MJ's four friends successfully advocated for change—getting Ms. Patricia to agree that MJ would be included in activities and his friends would be consulted about his needs—Shanice went to the lounge where MJ was sleeping.

What happened next was witnessed by Kelsey and the four boys:

Shanice stood over MJ's chair, both hands on his shoulders, shaking him hard. His whole body was rocking with the force of it, his head lolling. When Kelsey shouted for her to stop, Shanice claimed she was "just trying to wake him up."

But the evidence told a different story. MJ woke up disoriented and confused, his words slurred, unable to process what was happening. His shoulder showed four distinct finger marks where Shanice had dug in—marks that would bruise purple within hours. He immediately began crying and apologizing, asking what he'd done wrong.

Shanice's response: "He's fine. He's not even hurt that bad."

The Aftermath and Texts to Devon

After being ordered to leave by Kelsey and confronted by Ms. Patricia, Shanice was suspended pending investigation. Her parents came to argue it was "all a misunderstanding," but left quickly after being shown photographs of MJ's bruised shoulder.

That night, Shanice texted Devon repeatedly, expecting him to have her back:

  • "everyone's turning on me and you won't even answer??"
  • "i didn't even hurt him that bad. he's fine. everyone's making such a big deal out of nothing"
  • "i was trying to help him"

When Devon pushed back, telling her she'd hurt a child, Shanice's responses revealed her true feelings:

  • "barely! and he was being difficult. you know how he is"
  • "omg you're seriously doing this? you're taking THEIR side?"

And then, the message that broke Devon completely:

  • "are you seriously breaking up with me over this?? over some retarded kid who doesn't even know what's happening half the time? who just sleeps all day like a lazy piece of shit?"

The slur—used deliberately, with contempt—showed that Shanice hadn't seen MJ as fully human. That his disability made him, in her eyes, less deserving of basic dignity and protection.

Family and Core Relationships

[Shanice's family relationships were not extensively documented. Her parents were briefly mentioned during the suspension meeting—they came to argue it was "all a misunderstanding" but left quickly after being shown photographs of MJ's bruised shoulder.]

Romantic / Significant Relationships

Devon Morgan

Shanice and Devon began dating approximately three months before the Summer 2014 crisis, starting after they hooked up at a party. From the beginning, the relationship was defined more by Shanice's initiative than Devon's enthusiasm—she told people they were together; he just went along with it.

The relationship was toxic in ways Devon was too depressed and apathetic to fully recognize. Shanice made comments about his lack of ambition, his laziness, his failure to live up to potential—echoing what he already heard from his parents but framing it as concern from a girlfriend. She used his compliance and proximity to reinforce her social position at the rec center.

Devon's presence as her boyfriend meant complicity in her cruelty. His silence when she dismissed MJ, his going along with her hierarchy, his failure to challenge her—all of it enabled her behavior to continue unchecked.

The breakup came the night of the assault, after Shanice used the r-slur. Devon threw his phone across the room, blocked her number, and sent emails to Ms. Patricia confirming what he'd witnessed. Shanice responded by posting on Facebook, painting herself as the victim and Devon as a "fake snake."

The Social Media Fallout

After the breakup, Shanice took to Facebook with a carefully rewritten version of events that painted her as the victim. She portrayed Devon as someone who'd betrayed her, who was "fake," who'd turned on her for no reason.

People who barely knew Devon piled on, ready to believe the worst about the quiet rich kid from Roland Park. The comments revealed how easily strangers would condemn someone based on assumptions: "always been weird," "too quiet," "thinks he's better than everyone."

For Devon, the social media attack added another layer of hurt—not because he cared what Shanice thought, but because strangers who'd never tried to know him were so ready to tear him down based on appearances.

What Shanice Represents

Shanice functioned in this narrative as an illustration of how power corrupts small spaces. She wasn't an unusual monster—she was someone who'd been given social power and used it cruelly because no one stopped her. The other volunteers arranged themselves around her toxicity in different ways:

  • Devon became her complicit partner, his silence endorsing her behavior
  • Keisha became the fearful bystander, too scared of becoming a target to speak up
  • Marcus became the neutral party, choosing comfort over courage

One person wielding power + multiple people enabling it = systemic harm. Shanice alone couldn't have created the environment that hurt MJ for months. She needed the silence and complicity of everyone around her.

Her use of a slur against MJ—a Black woman using dehumanizing language against a disabled Black child—made her cruelty even more pointed. She knew what slurs did. She'd experienced the dehumanization of racism. And she turned around and did the same thing to someone more vulnerable than herself.

Legacy and Memory

[Shanice's legacy in the narrative was as a catalyst—the person whose cruelty finally became undeniable enough to force a reckoning. Her three-year reign at the rec center was built on the silence and complicity of everyone around her, and her escalation from neglect to assault was the moment that broke that silence. She functioned as an illustration of how power corrupts small spaces, and how the same dynamics of exclusion and dehumanization that operate between communities can reproduce themselves within them.]

Memorable Quotes

"He's disabled. Got some kind of syndrome or whatever. Makes him tired all the time. Can't really do much."

"Look, new girl, MJ's got his thing. He gets tired, he sleeps. We leave him alone. That's just how it works here."

"We work with the resources we have. We can't give special treatment to one kid just because he's got issues."

"He's fine. He's not even hurt that bad."

"are you seriously breaking up with me over this?? over some retarded kid who doesn't even know what's happening half the time?"

Characters Living Characters Book 1 Characters