Skip to content

Deborah Hayes and Evan Hayes

Deborah Hayes and Evan Thomas Hayes were mother and son. Evan was Deborah and Tommy’s only child. His trust in Deborah eroded as he watched her dismiss Tommy’s health and temperament, heard her attack the Matsuda family after Cody’s suicide attempt, and experienced her treatment of Pattie Matsuda during the summer 1998 pregnancy disclosure. Evan ended contact with Deborah and permanently excluded her from his family.

Childhood and Family Dynamic

Evan was born on June 14, 1982. He shared Tommy’s quiet temperament, methodical processing, preference for written organization, and discomfort in large social settings. Deborah criticized these traits in both father and son. She expected social ease and conformity to her standards and treated their need for time, structure, and smaller groups as shortcomings.

Tommy’s support gave Evan a different model inside the same household. He believed Evan’s experiences, respected the time he needed to process information, and expressed care through practical help. As Evan grew older, the contrast between his parents shaped which adult he trusted during crises.

Deborah came from a family with inherited wealth, while Tommy built his position through work in technology. Her concern with social standing shaped her expectations of Evan and the people close to him. Evan spent considerable time in the mixed-race Matsuda household, where he found direct acceptance of Cody’s and other family members’ disabilities. Those different environments gave him concrete alternatives to Deborah’s judgments; they did not make either family’s conduct an inevitable expression of race or class.

Cody Matsuda’s 1995 Crisis

In spring 1995, sixteen-year-old Cody Matsuda survived a suicide attempt and acquired motor apraxia that affected his speech. Twelve-year-old Evan overheard Deborah respond with contempt. Her remarks included:

“Well, what did they expect? That boy was clearly troubled.”

“I heard he can’t speak now. Brain damage. What a waste.”

“Honestly, if he wanted to die that badly, maybe they should have just let him.”

Deborah also called Cody attention-seeking, referred to him as one of “people like that,” described the Matsuda family as dysfunctional, and told Tommy that Evan needed to distance himself from them. Evan cried after hearing her, then rejected the instruction. He visited Pattie, brought her favorite snacks, asked about Cody, and continued his friendship with the family. The incident became an early break in his trust in Deborah.

Tommy’s Diagnosis and the Divorce

In March 1997, Tommy’s severe hemiplegic-migraine episode led to his first correct diagnosis after nearly twenty-eight years of symptoms. Evan learned that Deborah had repeatedly called his father’s pain and neurological changes dramatics or attention-seeking behavior during their approximately twenty-year marriage. The diagnosis clarified the repeated dismissal Evan had witnessed as a child and deepened his bond with Tommy.

Divorce proceedings had begun before the medical crisis. Deborah left Tommy for a younger, wealthier man, and the divorce was finalized later in 1997. Evan made Tommy’s home his primary residence. He retained some contact with Deborah until the following summer.

Summer 1998 Pregnancy Confrontation

Main article: Patricia Matsuda and Evan Hayes

Pattie and Evan conceived Lila in spring 1998 when both were fifteen. Pattie discovered the pregnancy that summer, after Evan had turned sixteen, and told him. Deborah learned of the disclosure and ordered Pattie out.

Deborah blamed Pattie alone for the pregnancy. She said that Pattie was trying to trap Evan, demanded to know how he knew the baby was his, and cited Pattie’s ADHD, school discipline, and history of fighting as proof that she was unstable or unfit. Her statements included “She trapped him,” “How do you even know it’s yours?” and “That girl has problems. ADHD, behavioral issues, gets in fights at school—” She also pressed the teenagers to “get rid of it” and said she did not care how Pattie got home. Deborah repeated the trapping accusation within her social circle, and it spread alongside other rumors about the teenagers and the party.

Evan stood between Deborah and Pattie and rejected the attempt to erase his responsibility. “Don’t talk about her like that,” he said. He answered, “It takes two people, Mom. I’m just as responsible,” and, “I trust her. If you can’t respect her, you can’t be part of this.” When Deborah continued with “That girl—,” Evan told her, “Her name is Pattie. And she’s the mother of my child.” Because Evan did not yet have a driver’s license, he called Tommy to collect them.

Evan connected Deborah’s attack on Pattie to her earlier treatment of Cody: “You did this before. Said horrible things about the Matsudas. When Cody was in the hospital. I heard you. And I hated you for it. You’re doing it again.” Deborah did not accept the boundary or stop attacking Pattie. Evan ended contact.

Estrangement and Lila

Main article: Deborah Hayes and Lila Hayes

The estrangement remained permanent. Deborah had no role in the pregnancy, Lila’s birth on October 28, 1998, the neonatal intensive care stay, or the family’s later life. Evan did not navigate between Deborah and the rest of the family or meet her at events involving Lila. He kept the boundary in place and raised Lila with Pattie, Tommy, and the Matsuda family’s support.

Evan’s response broke with Deborah’s pattern of control and dismissal. He believed Pattie’s account of her own body and choices, accepted equal responsibility for the pregnancy, and protected both Pattie and Lila from further contact with Deborah.

The estrangement also cost Evan the hope that his mother might support him through impending fatherhood. He was angry at her treatment of Pattie and Cody and grieved the relationship he had wanted with her. Tommy’s practical support during the pregnancy deepened Evan’s trust in his father without making the loss of contact with Deborah painless.

Evan’s decision shaped his response to Pattie’s medical needs. Her pregnancy involved severe nausea, the loss of medication support for her ADHD, and later preeclampsia; he took her symptoms and access needs seriously where Deborah had used her ADHD to question her fitness as a mother. After Lila’s premature birth, Pattie struggled with the strict pumping schedule while recovering from surgery and remaining off medication. Ellen framed formula as an accommodation, and Evan supported Pattie’s decision to use it. Evan met his three-pound, one-ounce daughter at 9:23 p.m. in the neonatal intensive care unit and gave staff the name he and Pattie had chosen, “Lila Marie Hayes.” He took part in her care and continued parenting with Pattie after she came home in early December. Deborah had no role in those decisions or in Lila’s later care.

Relationships Family Relationships Parent-Child Relationships Deborah Hayes Evan Hayes Hayes Family