Skip to content

Jacob Keller and Annie

Jacob Keller and Annie Whitaker met as client and trauma therapist in late 2022, when Jacob was fifteen. His mother’s murder twelve years earlier and subsequent foster placements had left him with severe trauma, and he had been referred to Annie after another placement change. Their weekly clinical work eventually developed into a maternal chosen-family bond that retained the history and care established in therapy. Jacob initially resented the referral and expressed contempt for the lavender-scented office and Annie’s accommodations for his autism and trauma, even as he kept accepting them. He arrived after years in a system that had largely given up on him.

Overview

Annie was Jacob’s therapist from fifteen through eighteen in a conventional weekly-session frame. Their last scheduled weekly session was in June 2025, shortly after his high-school graduation. She remained available afterward, but the relationship that continued through Juilliard, his career, marriage, fatherhood, and their mutual medical crises became maternal chosen family rather than lifelong formal treatment. Her care exceeded what either could describe through a clinical category alone. Jacob came to love her with a son’s dependence; Annie examined the strength of her investment in her own therapy with Dr. Beverly Klein, and the two acknowledged their attachment through their work together.

Origins

Around late 2022, a foster-care clinical coordinator who had worked with Annie on previous placements referred Jacob to her. Several short-term therapists and one longer-term clinician had preceded her. The latter was well-meaning but poorly trained and had treated Jacob’s autism-related communication shutdowns as conduct-disordered resistance. The coordinator described Annie’s referral as a last-best-shot on an older case before he ages out of specialty care.

Jacob’s file documented twelve years of system contact, multiple foster placements, misdiagnoses of his shutdowns as conduct disorder or attachment dysregulation, his mother’s murder when he was three, and no family contacts.

Annie read the file at her kitchen table on a Sunday afternoon and briefly cried. She signed to Robbie, I’m taking him. He understood what the decision would mean for her already full caseload and evenings and signed back, Of course you are. What do you need.

She scheduled Jacob for their first session the following week.

The First Sessions (Age 15)

Jacob first entered Annie’s Roland Park office around late 2022, at fifteen, wearing a loose jacket he kept on throughout the session. He noticed the lavender diffuser, which he associated with a curated safe space he had learned to mistrust, and responded with performed contempt. The room also had two warm lamps instead of fluorescent overhead lights, a small shelf of clinical and literary books, framed Hebrew calligraphy, a thick low-pile rug, and two armchairs angled so eye contact was optional. He chose the chair closest to the door and waited.

Annie was reading when he entered. She set down her book, signed HELLO without speaking, and said in her low, husky voice: Hi, Jacob. I’m Annie. You can keep your jacket on. You can sit wherever you want. We don’t have to talk for the first session if you don’t want to. I brought you a glass of water and set it on the table next to the chair you picked. That’s all. She asked no questions for forty minutes, returning to her book and occasionally offering the same sign without demanding a response.

Jacob watched Annie’s hands: broad palms, short strong fingers, a thin gold wedding band, and two right-wrist bangles that clicked when she turned a page. He neither signed back nor spoke until forty minutes into the session, when he said flatly, You know ASL. She signed YES and said yes aloud. He asked, Why. She signed and spoke, My parents are Deaf. I grew up signing. He remained silent for the final twenty minutes and did not acknowledge her signed GOODBYE as he left. He returned the following week.

Jacob took seven months to begin actively engaging. Annie used ASL when he became nonverbal, as he did in about half their first-year sessions. By the fourth month, she was giving him Uber vouchers for the trip home to Curtis Bay. Her text notification was always Uber voucher, use it, please. In session, she told him some version of I don’t want you on the bus at night, that’s all. He accepted the vouchers without thanking her and continued attending.

Jazz Piano and the Look

In Jacob’s first year of therapy, possibly early fall 2023 when he was sixteen, he arrived early while Annie finished notes in her back office. Her WBJC radio was playing jazz piano quietly in the waiting area during an evening jazz segment. Annie could not later recall or identify the track; it might have been Bill Evans or Monk.

Alone in the waiting area, Jacob hummed along for two or three minutes with his eyes half-closed. It was the first time Annie would hear him respond to music so unselfconsciously in her office, without the guarded posture he usually maintained there.

Jacob heard Annie’s boots on the hallway’s hardwood floor, her clicking bangles, and the keys shifting against her collar on their lanyard. He immediately straightened, stopped humming, set his hands on his knees, and made his face neutral, concealing the musical response she had interrupted. When Annie entered, she gave him the gentle, amused expression the family later called the look. She neither signed nor spoke.

Jacob blushed for the first time in their relationship and said flatly, Don’t.

Annie raised an eyebrow and signed, without speaking, Don’t what.

Jacob answered more slowly and defensively, I wasn’t doing anything.

Annie signed, Mmm, without pressing him further.

The look remained an unspoken recognition of Jacob’s need for music. In September 2024, Annie named Juilliard as a possibility, signing and speaking: “It’s not just for rich kids, Jacob. It’s for people who need music like oxygen.” She understood the unguarded response she had witnessed as evidence that music belonged centrally in his life, beyond the opportunities available to him in Curtis Bay. Jacob was furious at the suggestion, but continued thinking about it.

Weekly Therapy, 2022–2025

From late 2022 to June 2025, when Jacob was fifteen through eighteen, he and Annie met weekly in her Roland Park, Baltimore office. His engagement varied: some months included nonverbal sessions conducted entirely in ASL, while in others he spoke at length about experiences he had not shared with previous therapists. At different times, he resisted attending or leaving a session.

Annie signed when Jacob was nonverbal, directed her gaze toward the middle distance when he could not manage eye contact, and sometimes moved a session to a walk around Roland Park when he could not remain in the office. She neither charged nor kept count of his cancellations. The same office, chair, lavender scent, radio, appointment time, and signed HELLO at the door gave him a predictable start. She provided Uber vouchers after sessions for two years, until he aged out of his foster placement and no longer needed them.

By seventeen, Jacob was applying to Juilliard with Annie’s recommendation after having begun therapy in silence. He asked her to read and sign the letter to him before sending it. He cried silently through its final paragraph; she waited until he was finished and signed KEEP GOING.

Annie suggested Juilliard more than once without insisting and supported Jacob through the audition and application process without making her care contingent on his success. He was accepted with a full scholarship. At their June 2025 session, he finally shared the news he had kept private during Logan’s spring medical crisis and repeated it because he still struggled to believe it.

The Final Scheduled Weekly Session (June 2025)

Jacob’s final scheduled weekly session with Annie before he left for Juilliard took place shortly after his high-school graduation in June 2025, ahead of his fall move to New York City.

Jacob had grown taller and had begun to acknowledge how much he relied on Annie. He did not want their scheduled sessions to end and did not know how to say goodbye.

She said to him during the session: Your growth has been remarkable. Not because you’ve become someone different, but because you’ve learned to exist as yourself without apology.

Jacob needed several minutes before he could respond. He signed and spoke in fragments while trying to express what Annie meant to him. After saying You didn’t give up on me, he again fell silent for several minutes.

During the remaining session, Annie told Jacob that ending weekly meetings would not erase their work or the consistency they had built. She said that seeking therapy at Juilliard would not mean he had failed and that needing further help would not make him an imposition. She encouraged him to carry their work forward and ask for support when he needed it.

At the end of the session she signed GOODBYE and said goodbye out loud. She then added, signed and spoken: I am not going anywhere, Jacob. This is the ending of our weekly session work. It is not the ending of me. Write to me. Call me. You can come see me when you’re home.

He would, in later years, describe the session to his own eventual therapists as the first time an adult had told me I was allowed to leave and still be loved.

They did not end the relationship at the final session. They continued to correspond through Jacob’s Juilliard years. Annie continued to be available when he needed her.

September 2024 Session: Chloe’s Protection

In September 2024, weeks into Jacob’s senior year at Edgewood High School, he attended a Thursday-afternoon session at Annie’s Roland Park office. They had worked together for nearly two years.

For the first time, an adult named aloud Chloe’s act of hiding Jacob during her murder: “That she hid you in a closet when it happened. That she told you not to make a sound, and you didn’t”. The memory had remained central to his bodily experience of the trauma since age three. Annie knew about it from his file but had waited nearly two years before she judged that he could bear hearing it named.

Jacob thought, “She died protecting me from him, and I look just like him.” Annie’s words brought Chloe’s final act of care into conflict with his resemblance to Ben, which Jacob saw in his own face.

In the same session, Annie first suggested Juilliard aloud: “It’s not just for rich kids, Jacob. It’s for people who need music like oxygen.” Her earlier look after hearing him hum to jazz piano had not named the possibility. After this session, he continued thinking about it.

Annie also discussed Jacob’s recent fight with Mr. Gordon at Edgewood and his three-day in-school suspension without responding judgmentally. As usual, she provided an Uber voucher for his return to Curtis Bay, and Jacob began the session with his defensive arrival ritual.

Jacob’s Arrival Ritual

Jacob’s defensive arrival ritual helped him prepare to sit with an attentive adult. He entered with his hoodie up, headphones at his neck rather than over his ears, arms folded, and legs spread to occupy space and signal disengagement. He took the chair closest to the door without greeting or looking at Annie. She neither named nor interrupted the ritual and waited for him to settle before beginning.

By September 2024, Annie had seen the ritual nearly weekly for about two years and could read its variations. A quickly lowered hood suggested openness; headphones put on during a session signaled overwhelm; crossed rather than spread legs suggested an effort to occupy less space. As an adult, Jacob told later therapists that this was the first ritual he had been allowed to keep without being asked to change it.

Early Tests of Trust

Before September 2024, Jacob repeatedly tested whether hostility would make Annie end their work. The incidents clustered early in therapy rather than continuing throughout the two years. She responded without retaliation, withdrawal, or capitulation, and her consistency contributed to his trust.

During the first year, Jacob deliberately knocked a small ceramic lamp off the table beside his chair, watched it shatter, and waited for Annie’s response. The lamp was office decor without a clinical purpose. Annie acknowledged the breakage, swept up the pieces during a natural pause, and continued the session. She neither charged him nor revisited the incident in later sessions. The empty space where the lamp had been showed Jacob that an adult could absorb destruction without retaliating.

Jacob also described the specific steps and angles by which he could injure Annie’s face: the strike pattern, body mechanics, and trajectory. His cold, technical account drew on self-defense calculations he had made since childhood and emerged when he was overwhelmed. Annie did not flinch, call security, or end the session. She asked calmly whether he intended to act; he said no, and she answered okay before continuing. For Jacob, the response distinguished speaking about harm from carrying it out.

In another early session, Jacob threatened to hit Annie if she ever used the phrase trauma narrative. A previous therapist had used it to reduce his experience to a clinical category, much as that clinician had misread his autistic shutdowns as conduct disorder. Annie accepted the boundary without negotiation and did not use the phrase during the remaining weekly sessions or their later correspondence.

Together, these incidents showed Jacob that Annie would respect his boundaries without requiring him to earn that respect. By September 2024, that trust allowed her to name Chloe’s act of hiding him and allowed him to remain in the room as he heard it.

Communication

When Jacob could speak, he used direct, specific English without performing for Annie; she answered with similar economy. Their conversations reflected his autism-related preference for concrete language and her speech habits as a child of Deaf adults.

When Jacob was nonverbal, they used ASL. Melissa had begun teaching him at six to provide communication during those periods. His signing was competent, though not native, and grew more fluent through continued access. He signed compactly and directly. Annie slowed for him when needed, abbreviated signs when he was cognitively tired, and sometimes used the compact Rosen-family register of her childhood to convey her parents’ particular warmth.

Annie regularly signed and spoke what does your body know right now. Jacob initially flinched at the question because his body carried so much of his trauma. By the third year he relied on it, and in adulthood he used it as a private prompt.

Both were comfortable with long silences for different reasons. In Annie’s childhood home, silence meant the absence of signing rather than a problem; in Jacob’s foster placements, it had often been safest. They spent substantial portions of sessions together without speech or signs, and neither treated that time as empty.

Jacob’s acute hearing registered Annie approaching through the hallway before he saw her. He recognized her boots, bangles, keys, and humming.

Language and Cultural Exchange

Annie’s use of ASL during Jacob’s nonverbal periods carried meaning beyond a clinical accommodation. It was her native language, learned from her Deaf parents, and part of how they had taught her to include people they loved. Annie did not emphasize this dimension during therapy, and Jacob understood more of it only in early adulthood, after she told him about her parents and he met them.

Jacob was a white foster youth whose mother’s murder had fragmented his family and cultural upbringing. Annie, a second-generation American Ashkenazi Jewish Baltimorean, had maintained close ties to her parents’ traditions. As their relationship became familial, Jacob attended Shabbat dinners at the Whitaker-Rosen Family Home, adopted oy from Annie’s speech by his early twenties, and learned her mother’s challah recipe by heart without being able to bake it.

The relationship developed beyond the temporary roles the foster-care system had assigned adults in Jacob’s life, including caseworkers, therapists, and foster parents. Annie’s continuing presence after weekly therapy ended gave him a form of lasting attachment those formal categories had not provided.

Blake’s Influence

Main article: Blake

Annie’s grief for Blake, a young former foster-youth client who died by suicide a few years before Jacob entered her practice, intensified her investment in Jacob. For most of their relationship, Jacob did not know about Blake, who was not named in their sessions.

Jacob’s foster-care history and reputation for being difficult reminded Annie of aspects of Blake’s case. She did not treat Jacob as Blake but resolved, before finishing his file, that she would not lose another young client. Her therapist, Dr. Beverly Klein, identified grief-rooted countertransference that Annie worked through over years. It strengthened her commitment to Jacob without diminishing his care, although the additional emotional investment cost her personally.

In Jacob’s late twenties, Annie told him about Blake over tea at her kitchen table, outside a therapy session. Jacob was briefly angry at being one of two young clients she had held in this way, but moved beyond that response. He thereafter joined Annie in lighting a yahrzeit candle for Blake each year on the anniversary of his death.

Stroke, Hospital Vigil, and Seizure (2033)

In 2033, when Annie was fifty-five and Jacob was twenty-six, a cerebral aneurysm ruptured and caused a subarachnoid hemorrhage. Jacob, Logan, and Charlie were in her office as her right hand began twitching, her speech faltered, and right-sided weakness progressed to collapse. Logan, in his first postgraduate year of neurology residency, suspected an intracranial hemorrhage and directed the emergency response. Annie underwent emergency intervention and external ventricular drain placement at Johns Hopkins Hospital. Jacob remained at her bedside through intensive and acute care.

During one vigil, Jacob had a severe seizure beside Annie’s hospital bed. She recognized his distress but was too weak to reach the nurse-call control or help him physically. Her calls grew louder and more desperate until staff responded. The crisis reversed their usual roles: Jacob was there to watch over Annie, yet she could not reach him when he needed help.

Annie’s recovery took approximately eighteen months to stabilize. She retained a small number of longstanding clients while shifting more of her work toward supervision and consultation. Jacob was by then chosen family rather than part of her weekly caseload. Their visits, calls, and conversations adapted to her slower pace and need for rest, and he took a larger role in caring for her.

While Jacob rested at her bedside, Annie felt maternal pride in the adult pianist he had become. His performances combined emotional honesty with technical ability developed at Juilliard. She had helped him recognize a possibility but understood that Jacob had fought for his life and music himself. She was grateful to witness his growth and humbled by the adult he had become.

Maternal Attachment

Annie was one of Jacob’s longest-lasting adult relationships, alongside his ties to Logan, Charlie, and the Westons. She was among the first adults who offered consistency without asking him to perform for it and the first since his murdered mother, Chloe, whom he loved with a son’s dependence. Jacob did not regard Annie as a replacement for Chloe. She offered a different maternal presence without repairing that loss.

Jacob was formative to Annie’s clinical career and adult personal life. Her fear of losing another young client as she had lost Blake did not come true with him. She told Dr. Beverly Klein that gratitude for Jacob’s survival was the one emotion about her clinical career that had never diminished.

Both had learned that bodily crises could continue despite care and affection. The ICU vigil made the value and limits of their sustained presence for each other especially clear.

Caregiving and Interdependence

During weekly therapy, Annie offered clinical care, consistency, Uber vouchers, and flexibility about cancellations. After the formal work ended, she continued to offer counsel and a maternal presence. Her 2033 stroke changed the direction of their practical care: Jacob drove her to appointments, stayed with her during infusions, learned her signs of fatigue, and ended visits before she became exhausted. He applied the respect for another person’s limits that she had shown him.

They also took part in each other’s family milestones. Annie attended Jacob and Ava’s wedding and Clara’s birth in 2035. At the 2044 memorial for Saul and Miri, Jacob gave a eulogy in ASL that members of Miri’s Baltimore Jewish Deaf community continued discussing years later.

Privacy and Public Recognition

Annie kept Jacob’s client history confidential. At her request, Jacob did not name her in interviews or articles during her lifetime, although he referred in several publications to a long-term trauma therapist who became family. Annie supplied that phrasing to preserve the separation between her clinical identity, her personal bond with Jacob, and her ongoing work with other clients. Robbie, Saul, Miri, Charlie, Ava, and a small chosen-family circle knew the relationship privately.

Long-Term Influence

Annie remained one of Jacob’s three most formative adult relationships, alongside Charlie, his chosen brother, and Ava, his wife. Her continued presence taught him that an adult could stay and that accommodation could express love. He retained her question what does your body know right now, the Jewish household warmth he experienced at Shabbat dinners, and her insistence that music was a necessity in his life rather than merely a special interest.

For Annie, watching Jacob build an adult life remained sustaining throughout her clinical career. His survival did not resolve her grief for Blake, but her bond with Jacob developed alongside it. In post-stroke supervision, she used an anonymized account of their long-term work when trainees asked about foster-youth therapy. She did not name him, although people familiar with their history could recognize the relationship, and the account illustrated what sustained presence could offer.

Jacob carried their relationship into subsequent therapy, using language Annie had taught him to describe his needs and finding most later therapists wanting by comparison.

Relationships Therapeutic Relationships Chosen Family Relationships Jacob Keller Annie Whitaker Long-Term Relationships Book 1 Relationships Book 2 Relationships Book 3 Relationships Book 4 Relationships