Skip to content

Saul and Miri Rosen

Saul and Miri Rosen were childhood sweethearts who met in a New York School for the Deaf classroom when both were fourteen. They married at twenty-one and remained married for seventy-nine years, until Saul died in his sleep on a Tuesday morning in October 2044 and Miri died within thirty-six hours. She had told their daughter she was ready to follow him. Their marriage was foundational to the Whitaker-Rosen family, whose younger generations grew up with their quietly sustained partnership. In their private family shorthand, they continued to walk ‘’to the dining hall’‘: a phrase for the daily accompaniment that began when Saul first offered to walk Miri to the Fanwood cafeteria in 1958 and continued, in some form, for the next eighty-six years.

Overview

Saul and Miri were two Deaf Polish Jewish Holocaust child survivors who found each other young enough that neither looked for another partner. They built a marriage around lasting trust. Their temperaments differed: Saul’s broad mischief and theatrical signing met Miri’s quiet warmth and compact precision; his printer’s hands met her seamstress’s hands; his refusal to be tragic met her insistence on being present. They raised one daughter, Annie, and had three grandchildren, Lindsay, Leslie, and RJ. They were known throughout Mt. Washington, Baltimore, and preferred not to remain in separate rooms longer than daily necessities required.

Both had been saved by sustained presence, and they chose across decades to offer that presence to each other. Saul died first in October 2044; Miri followed within thirty-six hours. Their family later recognized the same pattern of deeply entwined care when Charlie and Logan died three days apart in 2081.

Origins

They met at the New York School for the Deaf (Fanwood) in the 1958–1959 academic year, when both were fourteen. Saul had enrolled at five after a period of functional language isolation in his hearing adoptive family’s New York City home, which he had entered at approximately three and a half. He arrived at Fanwood without signs and acquired fluent American Sign Language in his first years there. By fourteen, he was a known class clown, gifted teller of signed jokes, and behavioral handful. Miri had transferred from Boston’s Horace Mann School for the Deaf that fall because her adoptive parents wanted her immersed in the broader American Deaf culture Fanwood represented. She had reached her Deaf adoptive parents at approximately two and a half without a full language. ASL became her first full language, and she was fluent by approximately three and a half.

Their accounts of the meeting differed in detail, but both treated its ordinary circumstances as life-changing. Saul saw Miri across the classroom on her first day and decided, before he had any basis for it, that she would be his wife. During their third class together, he passed her a note combining written English with ASL glosses and asked whether he could walk her to the dining hall. Miri was more cautious than Saul and had learned from her adoptive parents to read people carefully. She considered the note for a full minute. Saul later claimed he had been dying of anticipation; Miri said she had been finishing a math problem.

Miri said yes, and Saul walked her to the dining hall. He made the matron laugh so hard that she forgot to reprimand him for lateness. Watching him, Miri decided that she had probably just agreed to the rest of her life, though she would not articulate that thought to herself for another year.

Courtship and Early Relationship

From that first dining-hall walk in fall 1958 through their graduation in June 1962, Saul and Miri were inseparable at Fanwood. They walked to the dining hall together, studied in the library, and signed to each other under their desks during class. Teachers and classmates treated them as a unit, ‘’Saul-and-Miri’’ said almost as one word. They did not break up and reconcile or fight in public. From fourteen onward, each was the other’s chosen default.

At sixteen, Saul made a clumsy but formal declaration in the library. With uncharacteristic seriousness, he signed, ‘’I want to marry you after we graduate. I’m telling you now so you can say no and I can recover before I actually ask you.’’ Miri answered with a decisiveness unusual for her: ‘’No need. Don’t ask until you can afford a ring. Then yes.’’ For decades, Saul called it the most efficient marriage negotiation in American history.

They graduated from Fanwood in 1962, at seventeen and eighteen respectively. Miri remained in New York City for seamstress training, while Saul began his union printing apprenticeship there. They saw each other daily. Miri’s adoptive parents came from Boston to meet Saul formally in 1963; Saul’s adoptive parents met Miri more casually at their Brooklyn home. Both families approved: Saul’s cautiously, Miri’s warmly and immediately.

Saul proposed in June 1965 on a park bench in Washington Square. He had saved from his printer’s wages for three years to buy a modest gold ring. He planned a solemn speech but collapsed into laughter halfway through; Miri cried and laughed with him. He signed close to her face, in small, careful signs: ‘’Marry me. I will not be funny about this.’’ His immediate, involuntary laughter broke the promise. Miri said yes.

They married in October 1965 in a small Jewish Deaf ceremony in Brooklyn. Saul’s adoptive mother wept throughout the service, and Miri’s adoptive father walked her down the aisle. The rabbi had learned basic ASL for the occasion and signed the blessings as he spoke them. Approximately sixty people attended. The reception at a Brooklyn Deaf social club included dancing, challah made by Miri’s adoptive mother, and a three-story cake Saul had bought with his last paycheck before the wedding.

Dynamics and Communication

Saul and Miri communicated daily in American Sign Language; neither spoke aloud. Over decades, they developed private signing that combined Fanwood-era New York ASL, Baltimore regional signs, Goldfarb-Rosen family inventions, and their own compact shorthand. Other ASL signers could understand most of their conversations, but some phrases, signs, and references belonged to the two of them alone.

Their different signing styles worked together. Saul signed broadly and quickly, engaging his entire upper body, often while walking, cooking, or holding a grandchild. Miri signed slowly and compactly, with precision, usually while standing or sitting still and giving the conversation her full attention. With each other, they adjusted: Saul slowed, and Miri broadened her signs. They met in the middle.

Their conflicts were usually quiet and resolved by the next morning without a formal ritual. Saul tended to joke past disagreements; Miri went quiet and let a joke fall flat until he returned to the issue. She usually prevailed in serious arguments because she was more patient and less attached to her own rhetoric. By their second year of marriage, Saul had stopped trying to outmaneuver her. In later life, he told Annie, ‘’Your mother always wins. I knew this at nineteen. It is the single most important fact of our marriage.’‘

They divided daily responsibilities in ways shaped by their era and personalities. Miri managed the kitchen, calendar, household finances, and child-rearing logistics. Saul took on community volunteering, extended-family diplomacy, the grandchildren’s bedtime stories, and the running jokes. Both participated equally in parenting Annie, grandparenting, and caring for each other emotionally.

Every night of their marriage, they signed to each other in the dark for twenty minutes before sleep, never longer and rarely shorter. Their signs were compact in the low light, sometimes reduced to palm-to-palm or fingertip-to-wrist contact. The ritual let them talk and steady each other. In her seventies, Miri told Annie, ‘’Those twenty minutes are the marriage. Everything else is the wrapping.’‘

Intimacy and Physical Relationship

Their physical intimacy was private and sustained. Their reserve about sex reflected their generation and upbringing: neither had grown up in a family that discussed it, and neither discussed it with others as an adult. By every available indication, however, their physical relationship was warm and active through most of their marriage. They routinely held hands in public from their engagement into their nineties. They slept beside each other every night of their seventy-nine-year marriage; during hospital stays, Saul arranged his cot to touch Miri’s bed, and Miri reached across in the dark to find his hand. They hugged in the kitchen and kissed before meals.

Saul’s physical affection had a larger scale: grand gestures, public hand-holding, and an arm around Miri’s waist while she cooked. Miri’s was quieter: a hand briefly on his forearm, her shoulder against his in a crowd, or her foot against his beneath the dinner table. Their shared physical vocabulary was specific and well established; each knew the other’s preferences.

Over decades, their physical relationship adapted to the progressive retinitis pigmentosa that narrowed both their visual fields. By their seventies, hand-to-hand contact had become more frequent, and touch took a larger role in communication than visual signing at a distance. The changes continued their closeness rather than interrupting it. They had always been tactile; the progression of Usher syndrome made touch more central.

Saul’s 1998 heart attack briefly interrupted their physical relationship. For the first and only documented time, Miri was afraid to touch him for several weeks. From his hospital bed, Saul signed firmly, ‘’I am your husband. I am not glass. Come here.’’ She gradually came back to him, and their physical intimacy resumed within a month of his recovery. It was not interrupted again until his death.

Domestic Life

Saul and Miri lived in the same Mt. Washington, Baltimore rowhouse from 1966 to 2042, seventy-six years in one home. The modest house had three bedrooms and one bathroom. Their son-in-law, Robbie, an architect specializing in accessibility, renovated it in stages between 2005 and 2035 as their Usher syndrome progressed. His changes included tactile wayfinding, adapted lighting, visual alerts, and eventually furniture arrangements suited to Protactile communication. In 2042, when both were in their late nineties and their vision and mobility had declined further, they moved two blocks into a custom-built first-floor suite at the Whitaker-Rosen Family Home. They spent their final two years there.

Their division of household work was clear. Miri ran the kitchen, and Saul’s cooking was limited. In 1972, he tried to make her birthday breakfast in bed but burned the eggs, scorched the toast, and set off an alarm Miri had to come downstairs to address. She made her own eggs afterward with characteristic quiet amusement while Saul sat at the table looking humbled. By 1991, he could reliably make scrambled eggs; he cooked them for Miri and Annie after Miri’s long disclosure of her rescue history. His limited cooking did not change their established division of work. Saul vacuumed, did laundry, repaired whatever broke, took out the trash, and washed the dishes after every meal Miri cooked. He handled other household tasks she requested without complaint through the remaining seventy-two years of marriage, and both were satisfied with the arrangement.

Their home consistently smelled of Miri’s baking—vanilla and yeast on Fridays, cinnamon and sugar on cookie-making weekends—and Saul’s Old Spice aftershave. Their oak kitchen table was scarred from forty years of use. It held their weekly Shabbat dinner and visits from Annie and her family.

Private Language and Shared World

The Rosens accumulated decades of private shorthand. Their central phrase, ‘’we walked to the dining hall’‘, expressed commitment: ‘’we are still us’‘, ‘’I love you’‘, or ‘’we made it through another day’‘. It later appeared on their shared memorial plaque in the Jewish Deaf Society of Baltimore community room. They used the phrase compulsively; their grandchildren grew up understanding it without ever being told its origin.

Their signed nicknames for each other were private. Saul called Miri ‘’Miri’’ in public and with family. Shortly after their wedding, he invented a sign-name used only when they were alone, combining the sign for MIRIAM, the prophetess and Moses’s sister, with a diminutive handshape meaning ‘’my own’‘. Miri made an equivalent private sign for Saul by combining his public sign-name with the ASL sign for HOME. Neither told Annie what the private signs meant. Their grandchildren speculated, but the family respected the couple’s privacy.

Their running jokes lasted for decades. The ‘’trained goose’’ came from Saul’s claim to six-year-old Lindsay that he had been smuggled out of Warsaw inside one; the phrase became family shorthand for his wild factual claims. Miri described the dill in her chicken soup, in ASL, as ‘’exactly enough dill to make a Hungarian jealous’‘, giving the household a measure of precision. Every Yom Kippur, Saul attempted to fast and abandoned the effort by 2 PM in favor of challah. Miri recounted the pattern each year with mock severity.

Their private world was built of accumulated small signs, shared references, repeated phrases, and the specific long-term texture of two people who had been paying attention to each other for eighty-six years.

Cultural and Family Context

Saul and Miri shared many cultural experiences. Both were Ashkenazi Jews of Polish descent, Holocaust child survivors, and profoundly Deaf from birth. Both were fluent in American Sign Language, practiced Reform Judaism, and participated in American Jewish Deaf community life. They did not have to negotiate whose holidays to observe, whose language to use at home, or whose foods to prepare for celebrations. Their answer was always ‘’both’‘, because ‘’both’’ often meant ‘’the same’‘.

Their upbringings also differed. Miri entered Deaf culture in early childhood through her Deaf parents; Saul entered through Fanwood at five. Her early-acquired ASL carried Boston inflections, while his carried New York ones. Miri’s family belonged to Boston’s established Jewish Deaf community; Saul’s adoptive family was culturally hearing, with Deaf members as exceptions. These differences caused little friction but gave their marriage a distinct texture. Each knew cultural references and habits the other had not grown up with, and they continued teaching each other across those differences.

Raising Annie in ASL was a deliberate act of cultural transmission. As the hearing CODA daughter of two Deaf parents, Annie was exposed to signing before her birth and grew up with it; Saul and Miri never considered raising her in spoken English alone. Her first word, at approximately eight months, was the ASL sign MAMA for Miri. Her second was an invented signed nickname for Saul that the family chose not to disclose publicly.

Caregiving and Interdependence

Saul and Miri cared for each other throughout their marriage, though the forms of care changed over time. In early and middle adulthood, it was relatively light and balanced. They supported each other through changes in work, Annie’s birth and challenging early years, the deaths of Miri’s adoptive parents in 1987 and 1994, and Saul’s father’s death in 1989. Neither held a primary caretaker role; both offered care.

Miri noticed changes in night vision and peripheral vision slightly earlier than Saul. Their relative needs reversed in their fifties as both experienced progressive retinitis pigmentosa: Saul’s field narrowed faster through his sixties, and Miri’s visual loss caught up later. They helped each other in overlapping ways. Miri drove after Saul could no longer do so, while her own vision still allowed it. Before Miri adopted a braille display, Saul signed passages from books she could not read in low light. Their accommodations were collaborative rather than hierarchical.

Saul’s 1998 heart attack was the first significant caregiving crisis. Miri managed his recovery with a methodical attentiveness that surprised even Saul—she had been watching him for forty years and knew, by instinct, what he needed when. His 2018 broken hip was a second caregiving period; Miri, then in her seventies with her own advanced retinitis pigmentosa, coordinated care alongside Annie and managed Saul’s rehab with the same calm thoroughness.

Their care remained mutual late in life. Miri began learning Protactile in 2012 to maintain direct communication with RJ as his vision narrowed; it became her primary face-to-face language in her late eighties. Saul also learned Protactile as the family’s communication needs changed. Between them, Protactile conveyed reassurance as well as words. Their daughter, drawing on her knowledge as a trauma therapist, had expected one parent to become the other’s primary caretaker in their final years. Instead, Saul and Miri continued caring for each other and regulating distress together until Saul’s death.

Parenting

Saul and Miri raised Annie together and remained highly present in her life. She was their only child, born in 1978 after a difficult pregnancy that precluded further children. Their focus on her could have become smothering but did not. Their division of parenting work reflected their era and temperaments: Miri provided most daily care in Annie’s early childhood, while Saul led play and told her signed stories each night. Both handled discipline, though it was rarely needed; Annie responded to their consistent structure.

Annie grew up bilingual in American Sign Language and English and signed before she spoke. She served as the family’s hearing interpreter during childhood, a role that felt natural to her. Only in adolescence did she recognize how the experience had also prepared her for her eventual vocation.

Saul and Miri took sustained pride in the daughter they had wanted deeply and had against odds they did not fully understand until later. Within an hour of Annie’s birth, Saul signed to a hospital nurse, ‘’This is the best baby in Baltimore. Any disagreement is wrong. Thank you.’’ He remained Annie’s strongest advocate. Miri cried and laughed at his declaration, much as she had at his proposal thirteen years earlier.

They did not attempt to have more children, though Saul had hoped for them. Miri’s difficult pregnancy and their physicians’ advice guided that decision, and both grieved the family size they had imagined. Saul channeled some of that energy into sometimes excessive involvement in Annie’s life; Miri later channeled it into expansive grandmothering when the twins arrived three decades later.

Public and Private Life

Saul and Miri were familiar figures in Mt. Washington, Baltimore, and in the Jewish Deaf Society of Baltimore. Strangers often noticed Saul first because of his broad physical presence, rapid signing, and public mischief. Miri’s quieter warmth and close attention to each person often made the more lasting impression. Acquaintances commonly spoke of ‘’Saul and Miri’’ almost as one word.

At home, Miri rarely performed for anyone, and Saul set aside much of his public showmanship. Their domestic life was quieter and more tender than their public manner might have suggested. Saul shared his filthy jokes widely; he reserved a different, less performative tenderness for Miri.

They received little media attention. A 1992 Baltimore Sun profile of Holocaust child survivors who had returned to Poland included Saul’s trip to meet the surviving daughter of his Żegota rescuers. Miri declined an interview because she had not made the trip and did not want to discuss her own rescue publicly. Saul gave a brief interview and, characteristically, told two contradictory versions of his smuggling story. The profile treated them kindly. The family kept a copy but rarely discussed it.

Relationship Timeline

1958: Meeting at Fanwood

Saul saw Miri across the classroom on her first day at the New York School for the Deaf in fall 1958. He passed her a note by their third class together. She said yes to walking to the dining hall. They were fourteen.

1962: Graduation from Fanwood

Both graduated in 1962 and committed to remaining together in New York City while Saul completed his printing apprenticeship and Miri trained as a seamstress.

1965: Marriage

They married in Brooklyn in October 1965, when both were twenty-one. Approximately sixty guests attended the small Jewish Deaf ceremony.

1966: Move to Baltimore

They relocated to Baltimore for Saul’s transferred union position and bought their Mt. Washington, Baltimore rowhouse within their first year. Miri began working at a Baltimore Jewish tailor shop.

1974: Founding of the Jewish Deaf Society of Baltimore

Saul helped found the Jewish Deaf Society of Baltimore in 1974 and remained active in its meetings and community life. Miri became a central social organizer, coordinating gatherings and practical support for members. Both remained involved throughout their adult lives.

1978: Birth of Annie

Annie was born after a difficult pregnancy. Neither parent later remembered a specific reason for choosing Annette as her first name; Saul insisted on Miriam as her middle name in honor of Miri.

1987 and 1994: Deaths of Miri’s Adoptive Parents

Miri’s adoptive father, Ira Goldfarb, died in 1987; her adoptive mother, Hannah Goldfarb, died in 1994. Both losses were significant to Miri; Saul supported her through both with characteristic steady presence.

1989: Death of Saul’s Adoptive Father

Saul’s adoptive father died in 1989. Saul’s grief was quiet and private; Miri helped him navigate it.

1992: Saul’s Trip to Poland

Saul made his only return trip to Poland to meet the surviving daughter of his Żegota rescuers. Miri did not accompany him; she had no desire to return. They stayed in touch by telephone: Annie signed and voiced with Saul in Poland, a U.S. TTY-relay operator relayed the conversation, and Miri typed and read at her text telephone in Baltimore. Saul returned changed. Miri held him for a long time when he came home, and neither signed anything for the first hour.

1998: Saul’s Heart Attack

Saul suffered a mild heart attack at fifty-four, was hospitalized briefly, and recovered with stent placement. It was their marriage’s first significant mortality scare. Miri stayed at the hospital and managed his care calmly and thoroughly; Saul continued to tell her for decades how much her response had impressed him.

2012: Separate Usher Syndrome Diagnoses

Their grandson RJ’s infant diagnosis with USH1F (Usher syndrome Type I, Ashkenazi Jewish founder variant) led to their own confirmatory testing in 2012. Saul was confirmed to have USH1F, while Miri’s clinically similar Type I Usher syndrome was traced to a different gene. The diagnoses were a reframing rather than a revelation; they had been living with the condition their whole lives and now it had a name. They processed the news together over a single shabbat dinner and did not discuss it much afterward.

2018: Saul’s Broken Hip

Saul fell in their bathroom in 2018, at seventy-four, and broke his hip. He recovered with rehabilitation, while Miri and Annie managed his care.

2042: Move to the Whitaker-Rosen Family Home

In their late nineties, Saul and Miri moved into a custom-built first-floor suite at Annie and Robbie’s home in Mt. Washington, Baltimore. Robbie managed the move with characteristic care. Saul had resisted it for approximately three years; Miri had been ready earlier and agreed as soon as he did. Annie argued that living there would let the grandchildren see them more often. Her argument persuaded Saul.

October 2044: Deaths Within Thirty-Six Hours

Saul died in his sleep on a Tuesday morning in October 2044 at one hundred, hours after signing a filthy joke that made Miri cackle. Miri died at home in her sleep within thirty-six hours, holding his pocket watch. Her physician presumed acute grief-related cardiac failure consistent with Takotsubo Cardiomyopathy; no bedside testing or autopsy confirmed the mechanism. Their family called it love. The Jewish Deaf Society of Baltimore held a joint memorial attended by approximately three hundred people, with eulogies that lasted three hours.

Crises and Transformations

Their major crises included Saul’s heart attack and broken hip, both partners’ progressive Usher syndrome, and the deaths of their adoptive parents. None ruptured the relationship. They faced each event together and adapted without fundamentally changing the marriage’s structure.

Their most serious marital difficulty came in 1979, during their first year with infant Annie. Miri was exhausted and isolated at home with the baby. Saul meant well but failed to understand how depleted she had become; he continued attending evening Jewish Deaf Society of Baltimore meetings as he had before Annie’s birth. After two months of growing distance, Miri signed to him at the kitchen table in small, precise signs: ‘’I need you here at night. I don’t need you to do anything. I just need you here.’‘

Saul understood immediately. He missed the next Society meeting and the ones that followed, staying home each evening with Miri and Annie for two months until Miri said she could manage his absences again. They did not repeat that kind of communication failure. Miri learned that, despite Saul’s habit of joking past difficult emotions, she could trust him with a direct request. Saul learned that Miri would tell him what she needed if he paid attention.

Emotional Life

Across eighty-six years, the marriage moved from intense young love through a settled domestic rhythm into late-life tenderness and anticipatory grief as their bodies declined. Throughout, Saul and Miri remained each other’s primary trusted adult. Their youthful intensity changed form without becoming cold or merely habitual. They continued the same practice of attentive companionship that began in a Fanwood classroom in 1958.

Saul expressed love through performance as tribute. He made Miri laugh daily, declared every Friday that her challah was the best in Mt. Washington, and told the family at every holiday that he had married above his station. Miri expressed love through sustained presence: signing with him in the dark before sleep, sitting through his Shabbat blessings even after hearing them ten thousand times, and ensuring he was never alone longer than either could bear. Over decades, each learned to recognize and receive the other’s form of love.

Anticipatory grief marked their final years. Both had lived longer than they expected and knew the other could die first. They did not discuss that prospect openly, but exchanged small private signs that acknowledged it.

Saul died first. Miri had long expected that she would follow him, and she told Annie she was ready. She did not resist or appear afraid of her own approaching death. After eighty-six years of loving Saul, she described herself as simply finished.

Legacy

Saul and Miri’s partnership shaped the Whitaker-Rosen family’s understanding of marriage. Annie and Robbie consciously and unconsciously modeled their long, stable marriage on Annie’s parents. The grandchildren—Lindsay, Leslie, and RJ—grew up observing that lasting partnership and carried parts of its example into their own adult relationships.

Within the Jewish Deaf Society of Baltimore, their marriage remained an example of the sustained commitment members valued. After their deaths, a joint photograph hung in the Society’s community room above a brass plaque bearing the phrase they had used privately throughout their marriage: ‘’We walked to the dining hall.’‘

The phrase became shorthand for sustained commitment within both the family and the Society. Their grandchildren used it with partners in adulthood, and Annie occasionally used it with couples in her clinical work. It outlived Saul and Miri by decades.

Their deaths within thirty-six hours became the family’s reference point for a good death: neither had been isolated, Saul had laughed hours before dying, and Miri had held his pocket watch during her final sleep. The symmetry became part of the family’s account of them for generations. When Charlie and Logan died within days of each other in 2081, surviving family members described them as having “pulled a Saul and Miri.” Within the family, the phrase conveyed the highest respect.

Relationships Romantic Relationships Married Couples Saul Rosen Miriam Rosen Deaf Relationships Jewish Relationships Holocaust Survivor Relationships