Skip to content

Jeremy Wallace and Clarissa Smalls

Jeremy Wallace and Clarissa Smalls began dating as teenagers in spring 1998. After two casual dates, Clarissa betrayed Jeremy’s confidence and their relationship broke off. Jeremy’s hospitalization in June preceded their reconciliation after his discharge in mid-July. They told each other they loved one another later that month, remained together through the fall, and eventually married.

Overview

Jeremy was sixteen in 1998, moving from his sophomore to junior year of high school. He was a wealthy teenager recovering from severe self-neglect, cardiac arrest, and an approximately three-week hospitalization that began on June 17, 1998. His crisis involved life-threatening malnutrition and dehydration without suicidal intent and left him managing epilepsy and the effects of medical trauma. His weight fell from 165 to 140 pounds. Clarissa was seventeen that spring and turned eighteen as she began her senior year; she belonged to the class of 1999. She came from a comfortable middle-class family. Her father, Robert “Bob” Smalls, worked as an accountant at a mid-sized firm; her mother, Linda Smalls, was a pediatric nurse who picked up extra shifts to help pay for her brother Michael’s Stanford education.

Clarissa learned to value substance over status, while Jeremy began to recognize his privilege and accept vulnerability. At first, Clarissa sought validation and access to wealth through him: “the mansion, the parties, the expensive gifts all made Clarissa feel like Cinderella.” Jeremy regarded their dating as casual and familiar within his social circle. Clarissa’s disclosure of Pattie’s pregnancy broke his confidence and led to vicious rumors, temporarily ending their relationship. Her decision to visit him in the hospital, and his later willingness to trust her again, changed the relationship from one shaped by performance to one grounded in genuine care.

Origins

In March 1998, Jeremy hosted a party at his mansion while his parents were out of town. Clarissa was a junior and Jeremy a sophomore. They connected at the party in a way both found significant and slept together for the first time that night. They began seeing each other casually afterward, drawn more by attraction and status than by deep knowledge of one another. In Jeremy’s words, they had been on “like two dates” and had not become an established couple.

Clarissa saw Jeremy as rich, popular, handsome, and able to offer the validation and status she had watched from the edge of his social world. Her family was comfortable but budget-conscious; Michael’s Stanford attendance cost twenty-five to thirty thousand dollars a year, and Linda picked up extra shifts to help pay the tuition. Jeremy seemed to offer access to a world without financial worry. His mansion, parties, and expensive gifts made Clarissa feel like Cinderella, as though she were dating “up” into an impossibly glamorous life.

Jeremy found Clarissa beautiful, popular, and well dressed. She belonged to his social circle, so dating her felt comfortable and easy. She was known for gossiping, but he did not take it seriously then. She was a familiar person to speak with when he felt lonely. Neither knew much about the other beyond the social personas they presented.

Dynamics and Communication

The way Jeremy and Clarissa spoke to each other changed through crisis. In fall 1998, Clarissa made direct observations about wealth and class without being cruel. Jeremy responded by questioning his own assumptions, asking, “Do you think I’m like that?” Clarissa was patient with his recovery limitations and did not rush or pressure him. She said “I love you” clearly and confidently. She was protective without being patronizing, making room for his vulnerability while maintaining her own strength.

Jeremy questioned his behavior and admitted, “I have no idea how to change that. But I want to try,” expressing a willingness to grow even when he did not know how. He was grateful for Clarissa’s presence and wondered why she chose to stay. When he said “I love you,” he did so with gratitude and wonder at being loved while so vulnerable.

Clarissa also showed love through consistent presence and action: daily visits during and after Jeremy’s hospitalization, patience with the pace of his recovery and his medical limitations, and protection when he was vulnerable. She let him sleep on the mall bench, stayed through the dinner aura, and counted aloud to help ground him. She chose him over Sarah’s friendship, permanently blocking Sarah on AIM and changing her profile to read: “Real friends show up when things get hard. Fake ones talk shit when you’re not around to defend yourself.” She faced gossip without complaint, defending Jeremy to study group members who called him “damaged” and confronting his former girlfriends when they judged his mental health.

Jeremy showed vulnerability by falling asleep in front of Clarissa at the mall and during lunch, admitting his limitations and fears, and letting her see him at his most broken: gaunt, exhausted, and bruised from IVs. He trusted her with his recovery, including therapy and medical monitoring, and included her in family moments such as dinner with Katherine. His willingness to let her see him at his worst expressed trust.

Class and Family Context

Jeremy and Clarissa entered the relationship from different economic positions. The Wallace family held substantial generational wealth and lived in a Pasadena mansion. The Smalls family was solidly middle-class: Robert worked as an accountant, Linda was a pediatric nurse who sometimes took extra shifts, and Michael’s Stanford tuition required careful budgeting. Clarissa was initially attracted to Jeremy’s wealth and status and experienced his interest as a Cinderella-like entry into his world.

Clarissa later recognized that she had first seen Jeremy partly as access to wealth, as other people did, and felt guilty about it. As she came to know his loneliness and vulnerability, she began seeing him as a person rather than as money or status. Her disclosure of Pattie’s pregnancy remained a breach of Jeremy’s trust; its consequences and her later repair were grounded in her choices rather than in a universal class logic of gossip.

Jeremy’s hospitalization and acquired disabilities separated his family’s resources from the realities they could not prevent or reverse. Clarissa kept visiting, supported him through fatigue and seizures, and defended him when peers treated him as damaged. Her actions demonstrated a shift from attraction to status toward sustained care for Jeremy himself.

Katherine Wallace observed Clarissa’s continued presence during Jeremy’s recovery and welcomed her into family dinners after the reconciliation. Her response to Clarissa and Jeremy was specific to their relationship, rather than a general rule about families with inherited wealth.

Shared History and Milestones

The betrayal in spring 1998 defined what they had to overcome. One evening when Jeremy’s parents were out of town, he felt upset and lonely about Evan and Pattie’s pregnancy. He confided in Clarissa and made her swear not to tell anyone. She promised. He told her that Pattie was pregnant; that he was worried about Evan and Pattie; that he thought they were too young and the pregnancy was a mistake; and that he thought Evan was throwing his life away. That was all he said—nothing more, nothing embellished, nothing cruel.

Clarissa told “just Sarah,” her best friend, because “it slipped out.” Sarah told Michelle, Michelle told others, and the story grew viciously embellished as it spread: accusations that Pattie had “trapped” Evan on purpose, suggestions that Evan had “taken advantage” of Pattie when she was drunk, implications that Evan was a rapist, questions about whether the baby was even Evan’s. These were vicious lies far beyond Jeremy’s simple expression of worry.

After a week of spreading rumors, Pattie—off her meds, pregnant, and pushed past her limit—confronted Clarissa in the courtyard. Clarissa defended herself: “I was just telling people the truth!” In doing so, she revealed Jeremy as the source: “Jeremy told me—” Before she could finish, Pattie punched her. Clarissa’s nose broke, blood was everywhere, the courtyard erupted in chaos, and Pattie was suspended for assault.

Jeremy called Clarissa afterward. His voice was flat when he asked, “Did you tell people?” She admitted she might have mentioned it to Sarah, claiming “it slipped out” and “It’s not my fault people took what I said and made it worse.” Jeremy’s response was simple and devastating: “You PROMISED me, Clarissa.” Then he hung up on her and broke off whatever relationship they had. Connor called Jeremy to warn him: “Evan might not want to be friends anymore,” compounding Jeremy’s isolation and loneliness.

Jeremy’s crisis began four days after school ended. School ended June 13, 1998, with Jeremy passing his finals. On June 17, severe self-neglect during a rapid depressive crisis left him unresponsive from life-threatening malnutrition and dehydration. He did not intend to die. He went into cardiac arrest, was hospitalized at Huntington Memorial Hospital, was intubated in the ICU, had his first seizure while in intensive care, and remained hospitalized for approximately three weeks.

When Clarissa got the phone call saying “Jeremy Wallace is in the ICU,” her stomach dropped. She knew instantly that she bore some responsibility—not all of it, but enough. She had promised him, then broken that promise because keeping it felt uncomfortable. Now his heart had stopped. Despite their history, Clarissa went to the hospital, apologized to Katherine Wallace, and waited in the ICU waiting room even though she could not see him. She returned day after day. On Friday evening, June 19, 1998, Jeremy woke after his breathing tube had been removed and asked whether Clarissa had been there. Katherine told him Clarissa had come by and waited. Jeremy nodded, then fell asleep again.

After Jeremy’s discharge, Clarissa continued visiting and supporting him. They reconciled in mid-July. Clarissa saw Jeremy at his most vulnerable—gaunt, exhausted, and bruised from IVs—and he recognized that her care was not a performance for status. She was patient with his limitations and protective without patronizing.

In late July 1998, approximately three weeks after Jeremy’s discharge, Clarissa took him to the mall for his first substantial outing. He was exhausted and dozed on a bench in public. She let him sleep, protected him, and did not rush him. Her former friends Michelle, Amy, and Sarah saw them together with Jeremy visibly gaunt and ill. On the drive home, Jeremy and Clarissa told each other they loved one another for the first time.

That evening at dinner in the Wallace house, Katherine saw Jeremy smile genuinely for the first time in months and felt grateful that Clarissa was bringing him back to life. Katherine told Jeremy, “You are allowed to be loved. Especially now,” recognizing that Clarissa’s care was genuine. On the Saturday night after seeing them at the mall, Sarah called Clarissa, predicted their relationship would fail by September, accused Clarissa of “playing nursemaid,” and disguised her judgment as concern. Clarissa stood up to Sarah in their final confrontation, choosing Jeremy over social approval and ending the friendship.

Public and Private Life

Their relationship faced intense social judgment. Classmates saw Jeremy gaunt and ill at the mall in July and spread more gossip about his condition. By fall 1998, he faced ableism that affected him deeply. At the Ritz-Carlton Huntington Hotel restaurant, he fell asleep at the table from chronic fatigue and heard loud comments from nearby wealthy parents about “teenagers on drugs” and “what kind of parents let their kids come to a place like this in that condition.” In the cafeteria, peers made cruel observations when he fell asleep during lunch: “Is he high?” “He looks like shit.” “Maybe he should go home if he can’t even stay awake.” One boy laughed: “Dude’s a mess.”

Members of the study group in the library called Jeremy “damaged,” prompting Clarissa to confront them directly: “He’s not damaged. He’s recovering. There’s a difference. And if you can’t see that, that says more about you than it does about him.” Clarissa also defended Jeremy against former girlfriends who spoke of his mental health with pity and judgment—girls who had dated him when he threw mansion parties but disappeared when things became difficult. She called out their hypocrisy publicly: “Where were you when he was in the hospital? Where were you during the hard parts? You don’t get to comment on his mental health now when you couldn’t be bothered to show up when it mattered.”

Some of Clarissa’s former friends judged their relationship. When she defended it at the froyo shop in September, insisting “It’s not about the money,” they reduced Jeremy to surface traits (“rich and hot”). Amy offered unexpected support: “I think it’s really cool you stayed. After everything. A lot of people would have bailed… Because it got hard. And scary. And not fun anymore.” Clarissa responded, “He’d stay for me.”

In private, their relationship centered on Jeremy’s recovery and their growing intimacy. Clarissa brought him out gradually, including on the mall trip, let him rest when he needed to, and did not push him beyond his limits. She celebrated small victories, such as his leaving the house and smiling. Jeremy let her see his limitations, fell asleep in public without hiding it, admitted his exhaustion and fears about returning to school, and processed his trauma with her present.

The Coach bag incident in late August 1998 revealed how they expressed and received love. While shopping for school supplies, Jeremy spent two hundred forty-seven dollars and sixty-three cents without thought. When Clarissa looked at a Coach bag priced at two hundred sixty-eight dollars, he immediately tried to buy it. She refused, shocked by the price. The refusal triggered Jeremy’s rejection sensitivity dysphoria: he experienced a rejected gift as a personal rejection. Clarissa realized that gift-giving was his primary way of expressing love, learned from David, who had taught him that love meant providing the best. For Jeremy, buying the bag expressed care. Once she understood this, Clarissa accepted it, recognizing what the gift meant to him.

Emotional Development

Clarissa gave Jeremy consistent care that was not a performance. She was patient with his recovery limitations, protected him when he was vulnerable, and did not rush or pressure him. She saw him beyond his money and status. After seeing him gaunt, exhausted, and traumatized, she loved him and stayed. Her presence helped him feel worthy of love, echoing Katherine’s words: “You are allowed to be loved.”

Clarissa also challenged Jeremy to grow. She noticed his unconscious habits around wealth and the class differences between them. She recognized his privilege without judging him cruelly and gently helped him identify those patterns. She buffered him socially by facing gossip and judgment, standing up to former friends, and choosing him over social position. Her choice helped him feel worth choosing.

Jeremy gave Clarissa vulnerability and trust. He let her see him at his lowest and trusted her again despite her betrayal. By being himself rather than performing wealth or status, he showed her the value of genuine connection. Their relationship challenged her to choose substance over status, stand up to a toxic friend group, value connection over gossip, and become the person she wanted to be.

Jeremy saw Clarissa beyond her appearance. He began to know her more fully, appreciated her devotion, felt grateful for her care, and valued her choices. His attention made her feel seen more deeply than the surface-level attention she had previously sought. Katherine also saw and appreciated Clarissa, welcomed her into the Wallace home, and treated her as important to Jeremy’s recovery.

Jeremy’s breakdown in September about being used for money revealed his deepest fear: “Everyone just uses me for my money. That’s all I am to people. That’s all I’ve ever been.” Expressing that fear about his worth became a turning point. Clarissa had initially seen him as access to a lifestyle and had been dazzled by his mansion and gifts. She had also shown up at the hospital, sat through migraines and auras, and stayed when he had nothing to offer but vulnerability and medical trauma. Her continued presence and patience showed that she saw Jeremy beyond his family’s money.

Health and Access

Jeremy’s conditions required extensive accommodation and support. He managed epilepsy with difficult-to-manage seizure patterns and medication side effects. Antiseizure medication caused fogginess and dampened his familiar energy and hyperactivity without functioning as ADHD treatment. He also lived with the aftermath of cardiac arrest, prolonged hospitalization, severe self-neglect, and medical trauma. His seizure auras included the dinner episode at 5:17 p.m. on September 8.

The first day of Jeremy’s junior year, September 8, 1998, revealed the extent of his challenges. Antiseizure medication made mornings foggy and heavy. The fluorescent lights at school felt like an assault: bright, harsh, and humming. Throughout his morning classes, he flinched at bells, endured the torture of tapping pens, and watched numbers swim during Calculus. At 12:17 p.m., he slept in the nurse’s office. Clarissa visited to check on him, watched him sleep, and thought he looked “so young, so vulnerable.” Maria arrived at 12:43 p.m. and drove him home, leaving his car at school. When Clarissa saw the car still in the parking lot at 2:47 p.m. but could not find Jeremy, she called the Wallace house in a panic. Maria told her about his migraine and reassured her that he was home. Around 3 p.m., Clarissa visited and sat with Katherine, watching Jeremy sleep. When he woke around 4:30 p.m., Clarissa helped him orient himself and gently massaged his shoulders, neck, and upper back.

The aura at dinner that evening, at 5:17 p.m., was the most frightening moment. Jeremy’s fork stopped moving. His vision blurred at the edges and tunneled inward. A falling sensation overcame him although he was seated firmly. He gripped the table edge, his knuckles white. When Clarissa asked if he was okay, he could not answer because of complete aphasia. He panicked: his heart raced, his chest tightened, and his breathing grew faster and shallower. Katherine moved to his side. Clarissa counted aloud, “One. Two. Three…” up to twenty, providing external grounding. David retrieved rescue medication. After approximately two minutes, the sensation faded. When Jeremy could speak, he described it: “Falling. I felt like I was falling. But I wasn’t. And everything got blurry. And I couldn’t talk.”

Katherine identified the episode as an aura and reassured Jeremy that it had stopped without progressing into a convulsive seizure, crediting his medication for limiting it. An epileptic aura was already seizure activity, even when it did not progress further. Jeremy nevertheless broke down completely: “What if that happens at school? What if I’m in class and I can’t talk and - What if next time it doesn’t stop?” Clarissa stayed with him, breathed with him, and helped him through the panic. When he cried “I just want it to stop. I just want to be normal again” and said he did not feel like himself, she told him firmly: “You’re still you. You’re still Jeremy.” After Katherine and David helped him to bed, Clarissa stayed with him in the dark room, holding his hand.

Crises and Reconciliation

Clarissa’s betrayal of Jeremy’s confidence about Pattie’s pregnancy led to rumors far beyond what he had said. Pattie punched Clarissa when she revealed Jeremy as her source. Jeremy said “You PROMISED me, Clarissa” before hanging up, and the potential loss of Evan’s friendship compounded his isolation. Clarissa learned that gossip had real consequences, that “it slipped out” did not excuse her, and that broken trust could destroy a relationship. She had to choose what kind of person she wanted to become. Jeremy confronted the consequences of misplaced trust, isolation, and the vulnerability of confiding in someone.

Jeremy’s hospitalization changed their relationship. Severe self-neglect without suicidal intent led to malnutrition, dehydration, cardiac arrest, intubation, anoxic injury, and his first seizure in intensive care. He remained in the hospital for approximately three weeks. When Clarissa heard that Jeremy was in the ICU, she came to the hospital, apologized to Katherine, waited even when she could not see him, and kept returning.

Clarissa’s presence when Jeremy was ill showed him care that was genuine rather than performed for social approval. Katherine observed her devotion. The betrayal no longer defined their relationship: Clarissa’s continued actions mattered alongside her past mistake, and Jeremy’s vulnerability gave them an opportunity to connect more deeply. They came to understand that showing up mattered more than past mistakes, that genuine care could endure a history of betrayal, and that crisis could reveal who was willing to stay.

Their reconciliation and growing love in July 1998 took shape through small moments. Clarissa continued visiting after Jeremy’s discharge, and they reconciled in mid-July. They said “I love you” on the drive home from the late-July mall outing. Katherine told Jeremy, “You are allowed to be loved,” and Clarissa stood up to Sarah, ending the friendship. Jeremy and Clarissa eventually married.

Their relationship deepened through challenges in fall 1998. The Coach bag incident helped Clarissa understand that Jeremy had learned gift-giving as a way to express love from David. Receiving his gift with grace meant recognizing the care behind it. Jeremy’s description of giving as “the only way I know how” exposed the limits of how he knew to express love, while Clarissa showed him her way of loving: being present when things were hard.

On October 20, 1998, Jeremy and Clarissa were eating at McDonald’s when Pattie arrived with Evan, Morgan, and Todd. The encounter began awkwardly, with Clarissa nervous and Jeremy holding her hand. Pattie apologized for punching Clarissa and breaking her nose; Clarissa apologized for telling Sarah and contributing to what followed. Each forgave the other. Clarissa corrected Pattie’s statement that she had almost killed her, acknowledging the injury without accepting that description. Afterward, the groups could remain in the restaurant without avoiding one another. Clarissa told Jeremy that she had not expected Pattie’s apology but was glad she had made it.

The concert tickets (October 24, 1998 Backstreet Boys at The Forum) represented Jeremy’s first concert planning. Floor seats cost two hundred dollars each. A mid-October seizure threatened the outing, and Jeremy remained determined to attend, telling Clarissa, “I’m not letting seizures stop me from living.” On October 24, another medical crisis prevented him from going. He arranged for Clarissa and Pattie to use the tickets instead, with money for dinner and souvenirs. Clarissa attended with Pattie four days after their mutual apology, and she felt Lila kick during the music. The gift made their evening possible even though Jeremy could not share it.

In the days after his breakdown in Clarissa’s car about being used for money, Jeremy gave her a custom silver charm bracelet with three charms he had chosen beforehand: a book because she wanted to study literature in college, a star because she had once mentioned wishing on stars as a child, and a heart with an infinity symbol. He had hidden it behind his complete Shakespeare collection and had intended it as a three-month anniversary gift. Clarissa agreed to receive it two weeks early because she knew giving it would make him happy. She was moved by the specificity rather than the expense: each charm reflected something he had listened to and remembered. His hands shook as he fastened it on her wrist. “This isn’t you buying me,” she told him, crying. “This is you loving me. There’s a difference.” For Jeremy, the bracelet was an attempt to give in a way that went beyond money. It showed that he had paid attention, knew her beyond the surface, and understood that love could take forms other than price tags.

Clarissa promised to wear the bracelet every day and described what she would tell people who asked about it: “My boyfriend gave it to me. Not my rich boyfriend. Just my boyfriend. Who pays attention and loves me and picked charms that mean something.” They agreed to have dinner at an Italian restaurant on the anniversary itself. The book charm reflected how often she read and how animated she became about English literature. The star recalled Bob teaching her to find the North Star. Jeremy also knew smaller preferences, including her dislike of cafeteria pizza and love of its breadsticks, which helped Clarissa distinguish his attention from the value of his purchases.

Lasting Impact

Their relationship reflected redemption and a second chance earned through action. Clarissa moved from betraying Jeremy’s trust to showing up when it mattered, from performing care to giving it genuinely, from seeking status to valuing substance, and from gossip to loyalty. Her hospital visits, daily presence during his recovery, choice of Jeremy over social approval, and defense of him against ableism helped rebuild his trust.

Jeremy learned to judge whom to trust after confiding in Clarissa, moved from loneliness and isolation toward feeling genuinely loved, and recovered from crisis with support. Clarissa’s gentle observations helped him begin to recognize his privilege and question unconscious habits: “Do you think I’m like that?” He wanted to change even before he knew how, admitting, “I have no idea how to change that. But I want to try.” His growing awareness challenged his earlier entitlement, while Clarissa’s love addressed his fear that people valued only his money.

Together, they chose their relationship despite the betrayal, social costs, class differences, judgment, and Jeremy’s recovery challenges. Their bond grew from superficial attraction into substantial connection. Their experience showed how earned second chances and a willingness to question privilege could change both partners, and how their actions during crisis revealed the care between them.

The differences in their experience of money taught both of them. Clarissa noticed the Wallace mansion, staff, and wine collection; Jeremy waiting for staff to clear his plate; his casual references to expensive brands; and the fact that he had never had a job. He had no concept of a budget: he bought nothing from Target and had never had to choose between two things because of cost. His five-hundred-dollar monthly allowance exceeded what Evan earned in nearly three weeks. Clarissa, by contrast, drove a used car, belonged to a family that saved for nice things, and knew that Michael’s Stanford attendance cost twenty-five to thirty thousand dollars and required Linda to take extra shifts.

Clarissa navigated the wealth disparity with grace. She defended their relationship against people who reduced Jeremy to “rich and hot” and remained aware of costs in ways he was not. Though initially attracted to his wealth, she came to see Jeremy as a person, taught him how she expressed love, and learned how he expressed his.

Relationships Romantic Relationships Jeremy Wallace Clarissa Smalls